Rating distribution for Thingol
Ratings
Mon 10th Aug 19:35
Very good "thinker's" duel map. One has to constantly weigh attack and defense options and deal with the shifting priorities. Well-designed.
Battle of Waterloo rated 
Superb
Superb
Very good "thinker's" duel map. One has to constantly weigh attack and defense options and deal with the shifting priorities. Well-designed.
Mon 8th Dec 09:27
Great board for both single player FFA and team play. The symmetry allows for some interesting strategies.
Great board for both single player FFA and team play. The symmetry allows for some interesting strategies.
Sat 16th Aug 00:12
This map is quite fun for 6-8 players...one must choose wisely on their attack/defense policies. Choosing the correct spot to place reserve units for defensive purposes is very key.
This map is quite fun for 6-8 players...one must choose wisely on their attack/defense policies. Choosing the correct spot to place reserve units for defensive purposes is very key.
Sun 18th May 12:52
Very cool map. This reminds me of the old Utopia intellivision game...and that's a good thing. The limit on visibility and waypoints make for interesting strategies.
Very cool map. This reminds me of the old Utopia intellivision game...and that's a good thing. The limit on visibility and waypoints make for interesting strategies.
Fri 11th Jan 15:02
Solid simulplay board. Students of WW 2 will like it. SquintGnome makes good use of unit placement enabling here to make attack/defense decisions more realistic. I tend to feel a slight edge for the German side, but a sly and/or bold Russian player can take control often enough.
Solid simulplay board. Students of WW 2 will like it. SquintGnome makes good use of unit placement enabling here to make attack/defense decisions more realistic. I tend to feel a slight edge for the German side, but a sly and/or bold Russian player can take control often enough.
Thu 13th Dec 23:32
I really like this one. It favors smart play, especially mid-game and the tunnels can make for an exciting and harrowing ending.
I really like this one. It favors smart play, especially mid-game and the tunnels can make for an exciting and harrowing ending.
Thu 13th Dec 23:29
One of the better simulgear maps out there. Nice graphics and game balance. Very good for team play.
One of the better simulgear maps out there. Nice graphics and game balance. Very good for team play.
Thu 13th Dec 23:27
A nice-looking map that is well balanced. I very much like this one for team play.
A nice-looking map that is well balanced. I very much like this one for team play.
Thu 13th Dec 23:25
A fun map to play and a nice concept. Something is off in the balancing, however, and therefore game placement has a bearing too often on outcome.
A fun map to play and a nice concept. Something is off in the balancing, however, and therefore game placement has a bearing too often on outcome.
Thu 13th Dec 23:22
Excellent for single player and team games. The game typically favors the bold. The map image has a very good look and feel, which adds to the fun.
Excellent for single player and team games. The game typically favors the bold. The map image has a very good look and feel, which adds to the fun.
Thu 13th Dec 23:19
This is a "smart" players map. As many folks mention, the use of vision is very important. The bonuses allow for good starting balance. Every once in awhile, it's just a fun map to play.
This is a "smart" players map. As many folks mention, the use of vision is very important. The bonuses allow for good starting balance. Every once in awhile, it's just a fun map to play.
Thu 13th Sep 13:17
This map favors intelligent play. Lots of options are available for winning...pacing is usually pretty quick. For games that become defensive struggles, be sure to grab a siege tank to remove bunker obstacles and/or remove your opponent's income.
This map favors intelligent play. Lots of options are available for winning...pacing is usually pretty quick. For games that become defensive struggles, be sure to grab a siege tank to remove bunker obstacles and/or remove your opponent's income.
Wed 15th Aug 21:47
Well-balanced, nice graphics and a fun map to play on either side. What's not to like? Steep initial learning curve, I guess. One finds new avenues of attack/fortify each game.
Well-balanced, nice graphics and a fun map to play on either side. What's not to like? Steep initial learning curve, I guess. One finds new avenues of attack/fortify each game.
Thu 26th Jan 00:40
Absolutely love this map. Very well designed and quite fun. Pacing picks up rapidly midway through a game.
Absolutely love this map. Very well designed and quite fun. Pacing picks up rapidly midway through a game.
Sat 28th May 11:51
A great board - beautifully rendered and with great diversity on gameplay...a true thinking-man's map.
A great board - beautifully rendered and with great diversity on gameplay...a true thinking-man's map.